Monday, March 17, 2008

The Limits of Written Discourse

Today I'm embarking on a journey into unknown territory and overused platitudes. I've decided to incorporate informal public writing, like the words that I write right now, into my first-year composition course here at TCNJ. The purpose of my course is to get students thinking about the ways that they might use writing to affect the world around them and it seems to be that blogs are working toward that end--there appear to be millions of these open journals floating about the internet and someone seems to be reading just a few. But my question is this: who is reading, for what purpose, and to what end? I keep thinking of all the things that I could write in this online space and keep finding myself constrained my my own shyness or sense of modesty. At what point does a public blog begin to interfere with my public face?

Blogs seem to exist in this no-man's land between private discourse and public discourse. If one has a Gmail account, as I do, then I don't believe one can make a blog private. And what would be the point anyway? I'm not inclined toward gossiping about colleagues (at least by name or institution), nor am I inclined toward saying mean things about my students or my relatives, so why would I want to keep this journal private and keep myself anonymous?

I suppose there's always the fear that I could be taken to task for bad prose, or for self-indulgent prose, or, worst of all, for grammatical errors! In the grand scheme of things, how bad could that be? Perhaps I could embarrass myself with a short list of my hobbies (paper-crafts--a clever euphemism for scrapbooking and stamping-- and knitting), although they are quite tame. My political inclinations are also quite public (I'm a Democrat for those who care, although I still haven't made up my mind about the election. I ducked the primary.). My own disappointments are fairly public as well: I received a few "we regret to inform you" letters this morning about on-campus funding--nothing I didn't expect. It's been hard to recapture my scholarly enthusiasm and energy after the birth of my youngest daughter. It's substantially more difficult to be a professional and a mother of two than it was to be a professional and a mother of one little girl who grows more independent by the day. Once I had two, my oldest seem to be more insistent about my time commitments to her. But all this isn't unusual.

So what am I so afraid of? Why do I fear letting my hair down in such a way that someone might want to read? Perhaps that's the fear itself: blogging presupposes that there are readers out there. And when a writer surrenders words to a reader, she loses control of their interpretation. She can't pull the page back. Once it's been read, the words are gone and in another's mind, never to return to the writer's control. Now I ask my students to do the same as first-year college students, albeit on a smaller stage. Our online courseware system, SOCS, has a blog function, so their writing will only be visible to their peers. But it will be visible to them. So, lest I be a hypocrite, I have to keep writing my blog which no one reads; just because someone might.

Saturday, March 15, 2008

New Words from the Field

According to the "dashboard" of Blogger, it's been ten days since I've posted any comments. Our students had tremendous success in Louisville, Kentucky, at the Sigma Tau Delta convention. We won a best chapter and best website award, two students won for writing two of the best papers of the convention, and two students won $4000 worth of scholarships. My goal for next year is for our students to win $10000 worth of scholarships from different sources, not just from the national organization.

In addition to some very bad behavior from certain south central faculty members (one made a student cry through the sheer force of her hateful polemic), I also heard a few innovative (at least to my approaching-middle-age ears) usages. On one short story panel, a student referenced the "Emo poetry we all write in high school" as she explained the point of her story.

I found this term an interesting semantic weakening or generalization. I thought that the qualifier "emo" referred to a musical genre of punk rock, exemplified by Fugazi. Clearly, it's a clipping of "emotional" or "emotive."

So I suppose this young poet intended "emo" to serve as a synonym for "adolescent angst." What I find so interesting is that her usage presupposes a dependence upon the conventions of this genre and subculture for the composition of this type of poetry; those of us with greater age can see that the poetry is simply a function of adolescence.

Wednesday, March 5, 2008

The News from "Lulville"

Ten students from our local chapter of Sigma Tau Delta, the national English honor society, are presenting critical and creative work at this year's national convention in Louisville, Kentucky. I'm eagerly anticipating rich regional variation, but, so far, all I've heard is the pronunciation "Lullville"--parodied to great amusement on local street signs. With any luck, I'll have more to report that is much more interesting.

Saturday, March 1, 2008

When research doesn't seem to pay off...

In stolen minutes here and there I've been trying to do some genealogical research to reconstruct the history of my oft-fractured family. My father and my maternal grandmother were both estranged from their respective families. The generations are so extended (my grandmother was born in 1881 and my father in 1913) that the records for my great-grandparents are very difficult to find on my father's side.

I almost feel as if I can find more evidence about Anglo-Saxon England than about my own family history. I'll continue to post as I discover more about Rosa Ellen Maxwell (my maternal great grandmother) and Samuel Steele (my paternal great grandfather).

Friday, February 29, 2008

Dictionaries in the News

Today I decided to add a "dictionaries in the news" element to my blogorama...How much do they come up? How are they used? Well, there's this gem from the NYTimes on Hillary Clinton's expression, a "bird-dog minute," courtesy of ever lexically dependable William Safire. If it isn't a southernism (bird-dog as verb appears first in a Galveston newspaper in the even more dependable OED), than it's certainly a westernism and something that should suggest that she is conversant with the practices of the outdoor sport.

And then, finally, I've been musing about "misunderestimate." It seems to have become a way to poke fun at Republican campaigners, but I fear that its constant use by CNN newsheads will lend it some credibility. What has been Bush's lexical legacy? How have his malapropisms poisoned our pool of words? In one hundred years, will Olympic high jumpers misunderestimage the height of the pole? And what would that mean anyway? Can one underestimate accurately to begin with? Just some philological thoughts...

Thursday, February 28, 2008

Nine minutes til the bus...

I guess one point of blogging is that one should write every day. Is this correct? Okay...well I have eight minutes until the first grade bus departs my daughter's school and I switch into full mommy mode. So I created a "tcnjenglishbooks" wiki where the TCNJ English department could start talking about our favorite books, or books we've read, or, I suppose, even books we wish to read. I wanted to be quiet about it, but word's gotten out and it's out of my control. I guess that wikis aren't supposed to be controlled. I find it all very disturbing.

More about dictionaries: I did a dictionary task with my students today in my writing course that I think was very provocative and says a great deal about how we read. I asked them to read George Will's editorial, McCain in a Glass House.

My students read it and got the gist of his argument that John McCain isn't as pious as he seems. Once I asked them to identify words they didn't feel confident about (anonymously--I wrote mine on the board: condign), we looked them up in my favorite, the OED. Then we worked over the text with the meanings in their head. They seemed to get more out of it a second time.

It still makes me think about the core question: how do readers decide if they're going to read dictionaries?

Wednesday, February 27, 2008

So you've got a blog...big deal. Who doesn't?

Well, I've started thinking a great deal about blogging. What does it mean to keep a blog? Is a blog a journal that you write and reveal to the world? Is it a public diary? Why would you want to have a public diary? Yuck.

But a blog might be a space where I can reflect on things that I worry about but don't vocalize; perhaps it's a space where I can say something scholarly in a way that won't bore people to tears. Then again, it might. Perhaps a blog might be another site of rejection: what happens if you write a blog that no one reads?

So I've been thinking about dictionaries a lot lately (another sigh from the non-existent audience--"What's new about that?"), and wondering why using a dictionary, apart from Dictionary.com, seems to be so difficult for so many people. In fact, I just came from a presentation where a colleague reported that her students (who are also my students) struggled with words like "paradoxically," "ubiquitous," and other words that I thought were "ubiquitous" enough in everyday college discourse that they should be able to recognize them. But do we ask our students to read so much so quickly that they fear stopping and looking up an unfamiliar word in a dictionary?

Or are readers afraid of dictionaries? Is there something intimidating about a dictionary? Do we fear being wrong about the meaning of a word? These are just questions...but perhaps I can find some answers.

Whew...no misspellings found. I guess I can publish now.